| Any club winning the cup for two consecutive years was able to make the cup the property of their club, and a new cup would be presented by Sir Charles Bine Renshaw, which was part of the conditions he laid down at the inception of the competition, these conditions have changed over the years. | |||||
| First Cup | |||||
| 1896 | Elderslie Wallace | 1897 | Inkerman | 1898 | Kilmacolm |
| 1899 | Barrhead | 1900 | Inkerman | 1901 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1902 | Gourock | 1903 | Old Kilbarchan | 1904 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1905 | Lochwinnoch | ||||
| Second Cup | |||||
| 1906 | Inkerman | 1907 | Barrhead | 1908 | Barrhead |
| Third Cup | |||||
| 1909 | Gourock | 1910 | Old Kilbarchan | 1911 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1912 | Gourock | 1913 | Lilybank | 1914 | Barrhead |
| 1915 | Bridge of Weir | 1916 | Elderslie Wallace | 1917 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1918 | Kilbarchan | 1919 | Barrhead | 1920 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1921 | Neilston | 1922 | Neilston | 1923 | Cardonald |
| 1924 | Cardonald | 1925 | Cardonald | 1926 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1927 | Lilybank | 1928 | Cardonald | ||
| Fourth Cup | |||||
| 1929 | Barrhead | 1930 | Elderslie Wallace | 1931 | Crofthead |
| 1932 | Lilybank | 1933 | Blacklandmill | 1934 | Gourock |
| 1935 | Barrhead | 1936 | Neilston | 1937 | Kilbarchan |
| 1938 | Kilbarchan | ||||
| Fifth Cup | |||||
| 1939 | Lilybank | 1940 | Elderslie Wallace | 1941 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1942 | Scotstounhill | 1943 | Kilbarchan | 1944 | Gourock |
| 1945 | Lilybank | 1946 | Birkmyer Park | 1947 | J G Fleming |
| 1948 | J G Fleming | 1949 | Cardonald | 1950 | Newton Mearns |
| 1951 | Hillington | 1952 | Linwood | 1953 | Kilbarchan |
| 1954 | Lilybank | 1955 | Lilybank | 1956 | J G Fleming |
| 1957 | Arthurlie | 1958 | Bridge of Weir | 1959 | Lilybank |
| 1960 | Bridge of Weir | 1961 | J G Fleming | 1962 | Blacklandmill |
| 1963 | Lilybank | 1964 | Kilbarchan | 1965 | Blacklandmill |
| 1966 | Linwood | 1967 | Linwood | 1968 | Linwood |
| 1969 | Lilybank | 1970 | Crofthead | 1971 | J G Fleming |
| 1972 | Elderslie Wallace | 1973 | Crofthead | 1974 | Nitshill & Hurlet |
| 1975 | Inkerman | 1976 | Elderslie Wallace | 1977 | Lochwinnoch |
| 1978 | Gourock | 1979 | Inverkip | 1980 | J G Fleming |
| 1981 | Nitshill & Hurlet | 1982 | Nitshill & Hurlet | 1983 | Crofthead |
| 1984 | Elderslie Wallace | 1985 | Crofthead | 1986 | Crofthead |
| 1987 | Inkerman | 1988 | J G Fleming | 1989 | Midton |
| 1990 | Blacklandmill | 1991 | Blacklandmill | 1992 | Barrhead |
| 1993 | Bridge of Weir | 1994 | Woodlands | 1995 | Midton (Centenary) |
| 1996 | Kilbarchan | 1997 | Shanks | 1998 | Barrhead |
| 1999 | Babcox & Wilcox | 2000 | Inchinnan | 2001 | Woodlands |
| 2002 | Blacklandmill | 2003 | Johnstone | 2004 | J G Fleming |
| 2005 | Ralston | 2006 | Lochwinnoch | 2007 | Renfrew |
| 2008 | J G Fleming | 2009 | Crookston | 2010 | Blacklandmill |
| 2011 | Shanks | 2012 | Ralston | 2013 | Crookston |
| 2014 | Neilston | 2015 | Crookston | 2016 | Lochwinnoch |
| 2017 | Elderslie Wallace | 2018 | Ralston | 2019 | J G Fleming |
| 2020 | Covid 19 not played | 2021 | Covid 19 not played | 2022 | Crookston |
| 2023 | Kilbarchan New Cup | 2024 | 2025 | ||